Built in 1769 by Samuel Wallis, the Muncy Farms Main House holds the title of the oldest house in Lycoming County because it wasn’t burned by allied British Loyalists and Native Americans in the Big Runaway of 1778 during the American Revolution. (In 1946, when the Archives of the British Revolution were opened, it was revealed that Samuel Wallis was communicating very closely with Major John André—head of the British Army’s Secret Service in America—so it is likely that the British gave orders to leave his house alone.)
The middle section is the oldest (1769) and was originally composed of four rooms. The stone section on the left was added in 1806. A Victorian wing was added in the 1800’s, but that was taken down in a big 1926 remodel, which also included adding the whole section on the right as well as a new furnace, plumbing, and electricity.)
A much oversimplified chronology:
1769—built by Samuel Wallis, who grows original 200 acres to 7,600
1778—not burned in Big Runaway because Samuel Wallis’ connections to British
1798—Samuel Wallis dies in debt because he overextended himself and property goes to the Girard Bank in Philadelphia.
1803—Henry Drinker (a land prospector) buys the property from the bank and sells it three months later to Robert Coleman (an iron furnace millionaire).
1806—Robert Coleman gifts the property and to his daughter, Elizabeth Coleman Hall as a wedding gift; the property stays in the Coleman family.
> William Coleman Hall (goes bankrupt raising, racing and betting on horses)
> Robert Coleman Hall Brock (Will’s cousin, pays debts and takes over property)
> son, Henry Brock inherits property
1923—Henry Brock is involved in a hit-and-run, killing three people and becomes first person to be convicted of vehicular manslaughter. (Very Gatsby-eque as there were two other people in the car with him and it was said that he was too drunk to have driven the car. However, he was the only person there when they found the car and he pled guilty.) While in jail, he sets up workshops to help inmates develop skills.
1926—Henry Brock is pardoned after three years of his 6-10 year sentence.
1926—Henry Brock and his new wife, Margaret (Burgwin) Brock, do extensive remodel to house
1940—Henry and Margaret Brock agree to take in British children during Germany’s bombing of England. The four Barlow children arrive just after Henry Brock passes away unexpectedly.
1961—Mrs. Brock passes away and the Barlows inherit the farm.
1972—Agnes flood, three feet of water in first floor.
I was so grateful for this video, where Malcom Barlow talks about his history, the history of the house and people who’ve lived in it and taken care of it; and that he let me come over and take pictures because I couldn’t find any online from the angle I wanted to illustrate.
Other sources:
Muncy Luminary, The oldest house in Lycoming County unfolds a story to behold
Muncy Historical Society, Celebrating 250 Years of Muncy Farms
Sun Gazette, Farmhouse is Oldest in Lycoming County